
Staff Writer Ella Shaw
Forget pumpkin and pecan pie. Reese’s is bringing back its three-pound chocolate and peanut butter creation just in time for the holidays.
Thanksgiving is about family, traditions, delicious food, and, of course, dessert. But this year, Reese’s is giving chocolate and peanut butter lovers something entirely different to put on the holiday table.
The Hershey Company has announced the return of its supersized Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Pie, a nine-inch creation weighing more than three pounds. The limited-edition dessert combines the brand’s signature milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter into one enormous peanut butter cup designed to be sliced, shared, and enjoyed like a traditional Thanksgiving pie. Forget the rolling pin, mixing bowls, and hours spent baking. Reese’s is offering a ready-made dessert that could give pumpkin, apple, and pecan pies some serious competition.
A Thanksgiving Favorite Makes Its Comeback
The giant Reese’s Pie first made headlines in November 2021 when Hershey introduced it as a limited-edition holiday offering. The response was extraordinary.
All 3,000 pies sold out in less than two hours, leaving plenty of disappointed chocolate lovers hoping for another opportunity to purchase one.
Five years later, Reese’s is answering those requests by bringing the oversized candy creation back for Thanksgiving 2026.
Unlike traditional pies, the Reese’s version doesn’t contain a flaky crust, fruit filling, or baked ingredients. Instead, it features the familiar combination of milk chocolate surrounding a thick peanut butter center, complete with the recognizable ridged edges of a classic Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup.
The result is a dessert that looks like a pie but delivers the flavor of one of America’s most recognizable candy brands.
Bringing Something Different to the Holiday Table
Thanksgiving desserts have always been part of the holiday experience. From homemade pumpkin pie topped with whipped cream to warm apple pie served with ice cream, families often have favorites that appear year after year. Reese’s is hoping its oversized peanut butter cup can become another holiday tradition.
The dessert is designed to be placed in the center of the table, cut into slices, and shared among family and friends. At more than three pounds, it’s considerably larger than the candy cups typically found in stores. For anyone who enjoys the combination of chocolate and peanut butter, the novelty of cutting into a giant Reese’s cup may be reason enough to add it to the Thanksgiving menu. And for hosts who would rather spend less time preparing desserts, the Reese’s Pie offers a convenient alternative that requires no baking.
How Much Does the Reese’s Pie Cost?
The limited-edition Reese’s Pie goes on sale Monday, November 16, 2026, at 9 a.m. Eastern Time through Hershey’s official online store. Priced at $49.99, the dessert will be sold on a first-come, first-served basis, with a purchase limit of two pies per order. Quantities are limited, and the company has not guaranteed that additional inventory will become available once the initial supply sells out.
Customers can also sign up for an email notification through the Reese’s Pie website to receive a reminder when sales begin. However, joining the notification list does not reserve a pie or guarantee a purchase. The dessert has also appeared in limited quantities at select wholesale club locations, although availability varies by store.
Interested customers can visit Hershey’s official Reese’s Pie store for purchasing information.
How to Store and Serve the Giant Reese’s Pie
For those fortunate enough to purchase one, Hershey recommends storing the pie in a cool, dry location at room temperature, away from direct sunlight and excessive heat. Refrigeration is not necessary. However, if the pie has been refrigerated, allowing it to return closer to room temperature before slicing will help maintain the intended texture.
The dessert can be cut into smaller portions, making it easy to share with Thanksgiving guests or save for another sweet occasion. With its combination of familiar flavors, oversized presentation, and limited availability, the Reese’s Pie offers something a little unexpected for the holiday season.
Whether it becomes the centerpiece of Thanksgiving dessert or simply joins the traditional lineup of holiday favorites, one thing is certain: Reese’s has found a creative way to make chocolate and peanut butter part of the Thanksgiving conversation. And after five years of waiting, fans of the original giant peanut butter cup finally have another chance to bring one home.
Well….Just know, I will have a couple of these. It is the holiday!
Ella!
Source: The Hershey Company, November 12, 2026, via PR Newswire. Additional historical sellout details reported by TheStreet.
